LESSONS FROM THE STEAM ENGINE
- Based on your experience, which of the causes of measurement failure hinders outstanding order fulfillment and customer service the most?
According to the case study, Lessons from the steam engine, a discussion builds up among the operational managers during their task force meeting. David narrates how their failure to meet customer demands had them move from heroes to zeroes. That was a big loss! Also, the causes of order fulfillment failure influence the technology in place for the operation. For instance, order automation is an effective and proven solution to avoid measurement failures during deliveries. Therefore, the application of manual systems in filling the order fulfillment gaps is one cause of measurement failure.
- Error in recording order; manually, order recording error can be prone to human error. Error results from miscommunications, misspellings, and inaccurate entering of amounts and tallying mistakes. Such errors commonly occur when writing, hearing, or recording data into a paper or an electrical device. Therefore, it hinders and delays order fulfillment to customers and clients.
- The packaging process for the order products. The packaging of orders for transportation occurs immediately after a customer has placed an order. The packaging involves materials that keep the item safe during transit until the point of delivery. In most cases, the packaging materials may not be strong and durable enough to last till it reaches the customer. Due to low quality, or poor packaging skills, the order is easily damaged before reaching the customer.
- Delay in order. Severally, customers have expressed dissatisfaction with services whenever delays occur during deliveries. Delays may occur out of the selector, the supplier, or the packager of order. It is a chain of the process that involve third parties to complete a delivery. In other terms, services delay due to slowness in packaging or late deliveries from the supplier. Such practices and challenges hinder effective order fulfillment.
- Misplaced inventory. Occasionally, in case of returns or damages, the pickers and packagers delay and fail to be keen enough to replace the order for a customer. The result is the displacement of inventory, thus leads to delays and inappropriate order fulfillment policies.
- Shortage of warehouse space. Interestingly, the number of goods is proportionally ordered following the size of the store. On a few occasions, you will find a firm ordering excess goods irrespective of its storage space. Inadequacy in space leads to a small amount of inventory in the store. Delays, the dissatisfaction of a customer, and inadequate deliveries result from a lack of enough space.
- How can you apply Paul’s analogous discussion of steam engines and long jumping (learning) to improve the design of your measurement systems?
Paul’s analogous discussion on the steam engine is an innovative idea that should be put into practice by most delivery companies. According to Paul, order measurement is the most critical element in achieving order fulfillment. Often, David’s team has failed in the right deliveries due to the inappropriate measurement of orders. Overstocking, among other mistakes, results due to assumptions and failure to take measurements. The application will ensure proper understanding and measuring of the possible outcomes of order fulfillment. Paul further suggests, in his arguments, the solution to the problem is not only a regional concern and focus but occupies global estimation in achieving a good market while remaining relevant.
Therefore, the application of steam engine discussion is a way of setting the pace of building an effective and responsive order fulfillment system. Besides, the steam engine’s idea recognizes the need for measurement before practice as a method of improving the understanding of order fulfillment capability. The application of Paul’s analogous discussion on steam engines is a remedy to poor understanding and no learning measurement failures. Its application will ensure proper understanding and measuring of the possible outcomes of order fulfillment.
- How would you respond to David’s final question: What should a world-class measurement system look like?
According to David, the need for a world-class measurement system seems to be the solution to achieving outstanding and effective deliveries. Companies are tasked with continuously reviewing their management chain; this review ensures relevancy in production and service delivery. Therefore, the best way to implement optimization options is by developing a world class measurement system. The world-class measurement system draws the attention of recognizing an organization or an industry as a benchmark tool by other industries. Often, it is considered the best among the available. The primary purpose of measurement systems is to provide an adequate performance level and analyze what is happening all around the supply chain management. Nevertheless, it is possibly easy to fall into the common trap of inefficiency and poor customer service without good measurement measures. Therefore, a world-class measurement system should have the following components;
- Sustainability; A world-class measurement system must be sustainably upright to cover a wide region for deliveries and have massive products for its customers.
- Meet customer’s need and demands; the customer’s needs and demand is the driving force behind every service delivering firm and organizations. Every hour, managers strive to improve customer service in their companies through training, sessions of interactions, and adequate communication among the employees. The measurement system should go above and beyond all the failures of order fulfillment operations. Thus, it should be actively satisfying customers’ demand without mismatch and destruction of products upon delivery.
- Convenient costs;
- Address and identify corrective measures; The measuring system should incorporate a workable cost of operations that proportionally considers the inputs against the output. Another component of a world-class measurement system focuses on putting pressure in the right direction to improve an order fulfillment operation. Again, the system should ultimately address and identify critical measurements by function, process, and activity. A world-class system should address both the short term and long-term emphasis on financial measures of an organization.
- Complete the chart above with your takeaways from analyzing the DWC case.
The team members’ ongoing conversation suggests their concern about developing a new and effective order fulfillment system. In their conversation, the need for a measurement system pops when Paul analogously speaks about a steam engine in giving his explanations. Again, according to Paul’s interjection upon David’s comment, he insists on the measuring protocols that previously their team has not put into practice. The key takeaway in his sentiments suggests the need to measure the right variables before deliveries. The discussion proceeds to the conference room, where David insists on mitigation measures towards achieving a workable and effective measuring system. However, he insists on no holding back and finger-pointing on individuals rather focusing on the mitigative measures.
The level of focus, in this instance, is a key takeaway demonstrating the procedure in problem-solving after a system failure. Lise and Tine introduce the world view idea of a measuring system. In their own opinion, order fulfillment is a cross-functional system that requires more attention in its development and operation. The need to make decisions is not based on individuals’ local measures, but globally, they should earn more customers and build a strong network.
References