Why impact drivers aren’t the best choice for loosening lug nuts
You can use a cordless impact driver to remove lug nuts; however, since that is not its primary job, the fasteners have to be in a particular condition for it to work. A lug nut fastened to a specific torque requires the same amount of power for removal if it’s still in mint condition. So if you have a lug nut tightened at around 100 lbs-ft, you should be able to remove it using a cordless impact driver that can deliver that torque power.
Why impact drivers aren’t the best choice for loosening lug nuts
Even though cordless impact drivers seem competent enough to remove lug nuts, they are not the right tools for the job, especially if working on fasteners tightened at a torque more significant than 100 lbs-ft.
The typical torque for most vehicle lugs ranges between 80-100 ft-lbs, but there are instances when they’re fixed even tighter. If you use a cordless impact driver to remove them, you’ll be pushing the tool too far.
Apart from being overly tightened, the lug nuts may rust over time. This could hold them in place at a higher power than 100 ft-lbs making it impossible to remove using a primary cordless impact driver.
What is the right power tool to remove lug nuts?
If you work on vehicles or do your vehicle maintenance from time to time, you should have an impact wrench in your toolbox. Impact wrenches or impact guns are more powerful compared to impact drivers. They can deliver torques higher than 200 lbs-ft, which is more than enough power to loosen even the most stubborn lug nuts.
There are three types of impact wrenches available on the market. These are air, electric, and cordless impact wrenches. Air impact wrenches (pneumatic wrenches) are the most powerful and the most popular among professional mechanics. They, however, require an air compressor, which means they aren’t suited for home use. Also, the attached air hose limits ease of use inside a garage.
The best impact wrenches for light use at home are the electric and cordless options. Electrical impact wrenches churn up plenty of power, but they share a similar limitation to their pneumatic counterparts. They require an accessible power outlet to work, and the electric cord will limit your movement.
Individual car owners and mobile mechanics commonly use cordless impact wrenches. Batteries power them, and even though they aren’t as powerful as air or electric impact wrenches, they still produce enough power to remove stubborn fasteners.
In terms of size, you should go for a ½ inch or ⅜ impact wrench. They are the best sizes because they produce enough power to loosen even the most robust fasteners without risk of stripping the lug nut. However, if you’re working on larger vehicles, we’d recommend using a 3/4 inch or 1-inch impact wrench.
Tips for using an impact driver to remove lug nuts
If you only have an impact driver as the available power tool, use the tips below to use it without risking damages to your fasteners or the tool itself.
- Consider the size of the lug nut sockets.
Different vehicles have lug nuts of varying sizes, so when you want to remove them, you have to choose a lug socket that perfectly fits them. If you use the wrong-sized socket, you risk damaging the head of the lug nut, which will make it harder to remove.
You can buy a lug nut socket set if you don’t know the exact size of your vehicle’s lug nuts. The most basic sets come with all socket sizes that can fit all popular cars.
- Get socket adapters
Most lug nut sockets are designed for impact wrenches with a square shaft head, which is a big contrast to the hexagonal sockets of impact drivers. You’ll have to find lug nut sockets with a hexagonal rear or get a socket adapter to connect the different sockets to work safely.
- Avoid chrome-plated sockets for lug nuts.
Both impact drivers and impact wrenches are high-torque power tools, and the regular chrome-plated sockets cannot withstand that much power. They may break or shatter as you work, which can be quite dangerous, especially when the metallic shrapnels fly everywhere.
It would help if you used durable impact-rated sockets because they have thicker walls that have been specially hardened to endure the high torque power of impact tools.
- Loosen the nuts with a manual lug wrench first
If your lug nuts are too tight or rusted, you may find it difficult to break them loose with the impact driver. In such a case, it is ideal for loosening the fasteners manually with a lug wrench and then using the power tool to spin them off. This way, you make it easier for your impact driver to do its job.
Conclusion
Impact drivers are primarily used for driving screws, drilling, and other construction-related work. They are also great to have as a mechanic for removing smaller fasteners quickly. Some of the new cordless varieties are even powerful enough to remove lug nuts; however, constant use on high torque fasteners will cause early damage to the tool.